Stowfly Logo

Package Stolen After ‘Delivered’? What Causes It and How to Handle UPS Stolen Packages

Blog Image

Protect yourself from package stolen issues and UPS stolen packages. Switch to Stowfly and keep every delivery secure!

Have you had your UPS package stolen right from your doorstep? Have you ever walked to your front door, seen nothing there, and thought “Great, my package is stolen”, you’re definitely not alone.Stolen packages have become a massive, expensive headache, and UPS stolen packages are a big part of that story.

Safewise survey estimated over 100 million stolen packages and about $15 billion in losses in a single year. If your UPS stolen packages situation feels personal, the numbers say it’s also very, very common.

Tired of packages stolen getting marked “delivered” when they’re not? Ship your online orders to Stowfly package receiving service locations and stop Amazon missing packages, UPS lost packages, FedEx stolen packages, and USPS missing packages before they start. Your first month of Stowfly is free!

How a Package Stolen Scenario Usually Plays Out

Most cases of stolen packages are simple:

  • Driver marks the package as “Delivered”.
  • The package sits visible on a doorstep, in a lobby, or outside a gate.
  • Someone walking or driving past grabs it in seconds.

Sometimes it’s even worse from the customer’s perspective:

  • The tracking says “Delivered”, but there’s no box anywhere.
  • Security cameras show the UPS driver never brought anything.
  • Or there’s a vague “delivery attempted” note when no one ever knocks.

Upset posts about UPS stolen packages often mention drivers marking things as delivered late in their shift, or falsely logging “attempted delivery” to protect performance metrics.

 While not every missing package is due to theft (misdelivery and scanning errors are real), stolen packages + bad communication = a lot of customer rage.

Suspect a Package Stolen? Start With These Essential First Steps

Before jumping into claims and customer support calls, it helps to make sure the package is truly missing. Many UPS stolen packages reports turn out to be misdeliveries, premature scans, or simple mix-ups. A quick initial check can save time, and make your claim stronger if the package is actually gone.

Step 1: Don’t Panic: Check the Basics Before Assuming a Package Stolen

Before you assume a package stolen:

       1. Check around the property

          Look behind planters, side doors, garages, apartment offices, or neighbor porches. Drivers sometimes hide packages to keep them out of sight

       2. Ask neighbors and household members

          Someone else may have brought the package inside without telling you.

       3. Double-check tracking details

 Confirm:

  • Delivery address
  • Time and date
  • Any “proof of delivery” notes or photos

      4. Give it a small buffer

          Sometimes UPS marks “Delivered” when the driver is still finishing the route, or a neighbor drops it off a bit later.

If the package still hasn’t appeared within a few hours and the tracking is clear, you can treat it as a likely package stolen (or misdelivered).

Step 2: Who to Contact First When Dealing With UPS Stolen Packages

A common point of confusion: your contract is with the seller, not UPS.

  • Retailers / marketplaces (Amazon, Walmart, etc.)

          Usually carry the responsibility to get your order to you. Many will reship or refund if a package is stolen after showing as delivered, especially if you’re a good customer.

  • UPS

          Is the carrier. They typically investigate when the shipper (the store or seller) asks them to file a claim. UPS has an online claims process for missing or damaged packages.(UPS)

  • You (the receiver)

 Are usually expected to:

  • Confirm the package isn’t simply misplaced.
  • Provide proof (photos, security footage, police report in higher-value cases).

Best practice:

 Start with the seller’s customer support and say clearly:

        “Tracking shows delivered by UPS, but I never received it. I’ve checked with neighbors and around the property. This looks like a stolen package.”

Most major retailers have internal channels to work with UPS on UPS stolen packages claims. If the seller refuses to help and you paid by card, your bank’s dispute process is the final backstop.

Step 3: How UPS Handles a Stolen Package Investigation

When a UPS stolen packages case becomes official (usually via a shipper claim), a few things often happen:

1. UPS opens a claim

 The claim is filed online or via a form. Tracking number, value, and description are required.(UPS)

2.Internal investigation

 UPS may:

Check GPS data to confirm where the driver scanned “Delivered”.

Ask the driver for details (where they left it, whether they remember the stop).

Review any available depot or vehicle camera footage.

Verification with receiver

 In some cases, UPS may directly ask you:

To confirm you checked around the property.

For photos or video showing no package was delivered.

For a police report if the value is high.

Outcome

If UPS accepts responsibility, they pay the shipper, not you directly.

The retailer or seller then issues you a refund or replacement.

Third-party guides estimate that carrier claim investigations often take around 7–10 business days, though it can be quicker or slower depending on the case.(Expert Beacon)

Step 4: How to Strengthen Your Claim When Your UPS Package Is Stolen

To improve your odds in any UPS stolen packages claim:

Document everything early

  • Screenshots of tracking.
  • Photos of your porch/entry showing no package.
  • Video clips from doorbell or CCTV cameras.

Be precise with timelines

  • “Delivered at 2:07 pm, I arrived at 2:20 pm, checked immediately, nothing there.”
  • “No door tag, no knock, no neighbor deliveries.”

Use the right phrases

  • “Package stolen after UPS marked delivered.”
  • “Delivered to wrong address / misdelivery suspected.”
  • “Sealed but empty box” (for cases where the box arrives but item is missing).

Follow through with a police report for high-value losses

  •  Some retailers and carriers require it above a certain dollar amount. Even if it doesn’t magically bring your box back, it makes your case look more credible and helps with insurance.

Step 5: How to Prevent UPS Stolen Packages in the Future

You can’t completely control porch pirates, but you can reduce your risk a lot:

1. Change the delivery location

  • Ship to your workplace (if allowed).
  • Use UPS Access Point® locations, lockers, or partner stores where packages are held securely until you pick them up.(Houston Chronicle)
  • For apartments, have items sent to the leasing office or a staffed desk.

2. Give clear delivery instructions

In the “delivery notes” or retailer preferences, ask drivers to:

  • Leave packages behind a gate, side door, or other less visible spot.
  • Avoid leaving them in a public hallway or exposed porch.

3. Use technology wisely

Video doorbells & cameras

 They don’t stop all porch pirates, but they:

  • Deter some.
  • Give you evidence for UPS stolen packages claims.

Real-time alerts

  • Opt into SMS or app alerts so you can bring packages inside quickly.

4. Avoid “package pileups”

  • For expensive items, try signature required delivery or schedule for a day you’re home.
  • Don’t let boxes sit outside overnight when you can help it.
  • Around peak seasons (Black Friday, holidays), porch piracy spikes as volume goes up.(CT Insider)

Package Stolen Laws & Policies: The Bigger Picture Behind Stolen Packages

Package theft has grown enough that multiple U.S. states now treat porch piracy as a specific crime, sometimes even a felony. One review found at least eight states with tougher porch piracy laws, and national estimates suggest Americans lost somewhere between $9–16 billion worth of packages in recent years.(Forbes)

Despite this, reporting is fragmented and a huge number of package stolen cases never make it to police reports at all, especially for lower-value items under $100, which make up the majority of thefts.(PR Newswire)

What Helps Prevent UPS Stolen Packages and Stolen Packages

Even with better laws, cameras, and claims processes, the reality is simple:

 If a package never hits your porch, a porch pirate can’t steal it.

That’s exactly where package receiving and package acceptance services by Stowfly help. Instead of shipping high-value or important items to an unattended doorstep, you can:

  • Send them to a trusted Stowfly location near you.
  • Have packages received, stored, and handed over only when you come in with a unique pick-up PIN generated specifically for you.
  • Reduce the risk of ending up in yet another “UPS stolen packages” nightmare, endless claims, or blame games between retailers and carriers.

For people who order a lot, live in shared buildings, or have had a package stolen before, using a secure pickup point isn’t just convenient, it can be the difference between “Your order has arrived” and “Your order vanished.”

If you’ve already had a UPS stolen packages incident, hopefully this guide gives you a clear path: verify, document, contact the seller, push the claim, and upgrade your delivery strategy so it’s much harder for the next thief to get lucky.

Learn how package receiving services on the Upper West Side solves NYC’s delivery dilemma in this blog.